Incident vs reflected metering: why snow turns grey, the 18% grey myth, and which mode to use when

An incident light meter sits at the subject and reads the light falling on it, so a white dress and a black coat both come out true. A reflected meter, like the one in your camera or phone, reads the light bouncing off the subject and turns everything mid-grey. Use incident for people and products, reflected for distant scenes.

The difference in one line

An incident meter stands where the subject stands and measures the light arriving there. A reflected meter stands where the camera stands and measures the light coming back off the subject. The first ignores what the subject looks like. The second depends on it completely.

What you can do today: put a white sheet of paper and a dark sweater side by side in the same light. Meter each with your camera or phone. The paper will read about two stops brighter than a grey card would, the sweater a stop or two darker. That gap is the whole reason incident meters exist.

The plate test: why snow turns grey

Every reflected meter is calibrated to turn what it reads into a middle grey. In a classic demonstration, three plates sat in the same light: white, grey and black. A reflected meter asked for f/32 on the white plate, f/16 on the grey one and f/8 on the black one at 1/125 s. Shot at those settings, all three plates came out the same flat grey.

An incident reading of the same light gave f/16 for all three. Shot at f/16, the white plate stayed white, the grey stayed grey and the black stayed black.

That is snow in a nutshell. Your camera sees a bright field and darkens it to grey; average metering underexposes snow by 2 stops or more. The same logic makes a black cat look charcoal, a bride's dress look dirty and a sunset look darker than it was.

Which to use when

SituationUseWhy
Portraits, people of any skin toneIncidentSkin and clothes do not shift the reading
Products on white or blackIncidentThe background cannot fool it
Snow, beach, white dressIncident, or reflected plus 1.5 to 2 stopsA reflected meter darkens bright scenes
Dark stage, black carIncident, or reflected minus 1 to 2 stopsA reflected meter brightens dark scenes
Distant landscapeReflected spot on a mid-tone, or incident if you stand in the same lightYou cannot walk to the mountain
Backlit faceIncident at the face, dome to the camera, or spot on the face plus 1 stopThe bright background drags reflected readings down
Sunset, silhouetteReflected, on the sky beside the sunYou want the sky right and the subject dark
Key and fill ratioIncident, aimed at each lampMeasures each light on its own
Zone system, high contrastReflected spot on shadows and highlightsYou place each tone yourself

How to take an incident reading

  1. Set the meter to your ISO.
  2. Stand at the subject, or put the meter exactly where the subject's face will be.
  3. Make sure the meter is in the same light: in the sun if the subject is in the sun, in the shade if not.
  4. Point the dome at the camera lens and take the reading.
  5. To measure one light alone, point the dome at that lamp and block the others with your hand. A flat diffuser in place of the dome is the tool for comparing lamps.

Incident results without an incident meter

Your camera and your phone are reflected meters. Three ways to get the incident answer anyway:

  • A grey card. Hold it in front of the subject, facing the camera, in the same light. Fill the meter's view with it and read. That is the same exposure an incident meter would give.
  • Your palm. Hold your palm in the subject's light, meter it, and open up one stop. Light palms reflect roughly a stop more than a grey card. Check your own palm against a card once and remember the offset.
  • A spot meter app. Tap the card or the palm on screen so nothing else enters the reading. This is where a phone beats a camera meter: you choose the exact point.

How to meter reflected light well

Look for a mid-tone in the same light as your subject: green grass, grey asphalt, weathered wood, a clear blue sky away from the sun. Meter it and use the reading as is.

Or place a tone on purpose. The zone system splits the scale into 11 zones one stop apart, with Zone V as the meter's grey. Meter the darkest area where you still want detail and expose two stops less than the meter says: it lands on Zone III, dark with texture. Meter bright snow and expose two stops more: it lands on Zone VII, light with texture.

Negative, slide and digital

On colour negative film, an incident reading or a reading of the shadows is safest, because negative film forgives overexposure. On slide film and digital, blown highlights cannot be recovered, so meter the brightest area that needs detail and place it, or trust an incident reading and check the highlights. For the full picture of meter types, see light meter, and for how far a phone reading can be trusted, see is a phone light meter accurate.

Questions people ask

Which is more accurate, incident or reflected metering?

Incident, for most subjects you can walk up to, because it ignores how light or dark the subject is. Reflected metering is just as accurate on a mid-tone, and it is the only option for subjects far away. Spot metering a chosen patch gives the most control of all, once you know which patch to pick.

Why do my photos of snow come out grey?

Your camera's meter is a reflected meter, built to make whatever it sees come out mid-grey. Faced with bright snow, it cuts the exposure until the snow is grey. Average metering underexposes snow by 2 stops or more. Add 1.5 to 2 stops of exposure compensation, or take an incident reading.

Can my camera or phone take an incident reading?

Not directly; both read reflected light. You can get the same result by metering a grey card held in front of your subject and filling the frame with it, or by metering your palm in the subject's light and opening up one stop. Test your palm against a grey card once to know its offset.

Where do I point the dome of an incident meter?

Stand at the subject, in the same light, and point the dome at the camera lens. That reads all the light that shapes what the camera sees. To measure one lamp alone, for a lighting ratio, point the dome at that lamp and shade it from the others.

Are light meters calibrated to 18% grey?

Not exactly. With the common constants, reflected and incident readings agree on a surface of about 15.7% reflectance, roughly 0.2 stop darker than 18%. The difference is too small to matter on negative film. On slide film, or when matching a spot meter to an incident meter, it explains the small gap you see.

Sources

Made by EASYTECH, who also make LightMeter Pro.