Reciprocity failure: what it is, and how much longer to expose, film by film
Reciprocity failure is film losing sensitivity in long exposures, so it needs more time than the meter says. Most films are fine up to about 1 second. Past that, Ilford's rule is corrected time = metered time to the power p: HP5 Plus metered at 10 seconds needs about 20. Digital sensors do not have it.
What reciprocity failure is
The reciprocity law is the rule behind every light meter: halve the light, double the time, and the exposure stays the same. f/8 at 1 second equals f/5.6 at 1/2 second. Kodak states that the law holds for most films from about 1/5 second to 1/1,000 second.
Push the time longer and film stops keeping up. In dim light, its grains need more than twice the time to catch twice the light, so a frame exposed for the metered time comes out thin. The longer the exposure, the bigger the gap. That gap is reciprocity failure, and fixing it is just a matter of adding time.
What you can do today: before your next night roll, write your film's correction for 4, 15 and 60 seconds on a piece of tape on the camera back. You will not want to do the maths in the dark.
The short answer
- 1 second or less: no correction for almost any film.
- A few seconds: add a little, about a third to two thirds of a stop.
- 10 seconds metered: most black and white films need roughly double, around 20 seconds. Tri-X needs five times as much.
- Minutes: the correction can multiply the time by four to twelve. Open the lens instead, when you can.
Ilford black and white: the power formula
Ilford gives one formula for all its films: corrected time = metered time^p, with times in seconds and p specific to each film. Worked example from Ilford's sheet: HP5 Plus metered at 10 s gives 10^1.31 = 20.4 s; round to 20 s.
| Film | p | 2 s | 4 s | 8 s | 15 s | 30 s | 60 s | 120 s |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HP5 Plus | 1.31 | 2.5 s | 6 s | 15 s | 35 s | 86 s | 3.6 min | 8.8 min |
| FP4 Plus | 1.26 | 2.4 s | 5.7 s | 14 s | 30 s | 73 s | 2.9 min | 6.9 min |
| Delta 100 | 1.26 | 2.4 s | 5.7 s | 14 s | 30 s | 73 s | 2.9 min | 6.9 min |
| Delta 400 | 1.41 | 2.7 s | 7 s | 19 s | 46 s | 2 min | 5.4 min | 14 min |
| Delta 3200 | 1.33 | 2.5 s | 6.3 s | 16 s | 37 s | 92 s | 3.9 min | 9.7 min |
| Pan F Plus | 1.33 | 2.5 s | 6.3 s | 16 s | 37 s | 92 s | 3.9 min | 9.7 min |
| SFX 200 | 1.43 | 2.7 s | 7.3 s | 20 s | 48 s | 2.2 min | 5.8 min | 15.7 min |
| XP2 Super | 1.31 | 2.5 s | 6 s | 15 s | 35 s | 86 s | 3.6 min | 8.8 min |
Ilford's sheet also lists Kentmere 100 at 1.26, Kentmere 400 at 1.30 and Ortho Plus at 1.25. Long exposures raise contrast, because highlights and shadows fail by different amounts, so Ilford suggests pulling development when the scene has a wide range of light.
Kodak black and white
Tri-X and Kodak's classic grain films need much more, and a development change:
| Metered time | Add | Corrected time | Development |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 s | 1 stop | 2 s | 10% less |
| 10 s | 2 stops | 50 s | 20% less |
| 100 s | 3 stops | 20 min | 30% less |
Between these rows, Kodak points you to its graphs; reading between the lines of the table gives a fair estimate.
T-MAX films hold up better and need no development change. T-MAX 100: 1 s needs a third of a stop more, 10 s becomes 15 s, 100 s becomes 200 s. T-MAX 400: 10 s becomes 15 s, 100 s becomes 300 s. T-MAX P3200: 10 s becomes 15 s, 100 s becomes 400 s.
Colour negative: Portra and Ektar
Kodak's data sheets for Portra 400 and Ektar 100 say no correction is needed from 1/10,000 to 1 second, and for longer exposures, "make tests under your conditions". There is no official number past 1 second. Colour negative film handles overexposure well, so bracket: shoot the metered time, then double it, then double again. Keep notes and you will have your own table after one roll.
Colour slide: Velvia and Provia
Fujifilm's professional data guide gives time and filter corrections for its slide films:
| Film | No correction up to | Then |
|---|---|---|
| Velvia (50) | 1 s | 4 s: +1/3 stop, 5M filter. 16 s: +2/3 stop, 10M. 64 s and longer: not recommended |
| Velvia 100F | 1 min | 2 min: +1/3 stop. 4 min: +1/2. 8 min: +2/3, each with a 2.5B filter |
| Provia 100F | 128 s | 4 min: +1/3 stop, 2.5G. 8 min: not recommended |
| Provia 400F | 32 s | 64 s: +2/3 stop, 5G. 2 to 4 min: +1 stop, 7.5G. 8 min: not recommended |
The letters are colour compensating filters (M magenta, B blue, G green) that correct the colour shift long exposures cause on slide film.
Add time, or open the lens?
Kodak's advice: when you must add exposure for a long exposure, use a larger lens opening if possible. Every extra second makes the failure worse, so opening up saves far more time than it seems.
HP5 Plus, a night scene metered at 30 s at f/16:
- At f/16: 30 s metered becomes about 86 s.
- At f/11: 15 s metered becomes about 35 s.
- At f/8: 8 s metered becomes about 15 s.
Two stops wider cut almost six times off the exposure.
Long exposures with an ND filter
A strong ND filter turns a daylight scene into a long exposure, and film treats it like any other long exposure. Meter without the filter, add the filter's stops to get the metered time, then apply your film's correction to that time. A 10-stop ND on a scene metered at 1/30 s gives about 30 s; on HP5 Plus that becomes 30^1.31, about 86 s. The correction always comes last, after every filter and every stop you have added.
Metering in the dark
Low light is also where meters, and phone meters most of all, are least accurate. Two habits help:
- Meter at a wide aperture and a high ISO, then count stops. Say the meter reads 1/4 s at f/2 and ISO 3200. Your film is ISO 400, three stops slower: 2 s. You shoot at f/8, four stops smaller: 32 s. HP5 Plus correction: 32^1.31, about 94 s.
- Meter the part that matters. A bright street lamp in the frame drags the reading down. Tap the lit facade or the area where you want detail.
The exposure value chart lists night scenes from EV 5 down to starlight, a good check on a reading that looks wrong.
Three worked examples
Night street, HP5 Plus. Metered 8 s at f/8. Corrected: 8^1.31 = 15 s.
Moonlit landscape, Tri-X. Metered 100 s. Kodak: three stops more, 20 minutes, and cut development by 30%. Open two stops if your lens allows and the metered time drops to 25 s, which by the same table needs a little over 2 minutes, a far easier night.
Blue hour, Portra 400. Metered 4 s. Past 1 second Kodak gives no figure, so bracket 4, 8 and 15 s. Expect the longest frame to scan best.
Questions people ask
What is the law of reciprocity in photography?
It says that exposure is light intensity multiplied by time, so halving one and doubling the other gives the same result: f/8 at 1/60 s equals f/5.6 at 1/125 s. Every light meter and every equivalent pair of settings relies on it. Film follows it from about 1/1,000 to 1/5 of a second.
What is reciprocity failure?
The reciprocity law says that half the light for twice the time gives the same exposure. Film obeys it only between about 1/1,000 and 1/5 of a second, and most films hold well to 1 second. In long exposures it becomes less sensitive, so it needs more time than the meter says. That shortfall is reciprocity failure.
Does digital have reciprocity failure?
No. A digital sensor records twice the light in twice the time at any shutter speed, so the metered time is the right time. Long digital exposures have other problems, mainly heat noise and hot pixels, which long-exposure noise reduction handles. Reciprocity tables are for film only.
When does reciprocity failure start?
For most black and white and colour films, past about 1 second. Ilford says exposures of 1 second or less need no compensation. Kodak Portra 400 and Ektar 100 need none up to 1 second. Fuji Provia 100F needs none up to 128 seconds, while Velvia needs a correction from 4 seconds.
How do I calculate reciprocity failure?
For Ilford films, raise the metered time in seconds to the power of the film's p factor: metered 10 s on HP5 Plus, p 1.31, gives 10 to the 1.31, about 20 s. Any phone calculator in landscape mode has the x to the y key. For Kodak and Fuji films, use the makers' tables on this page.
Sources
- ILFORD: Film reciprocity failure compensation (HARMAN technology, Dec 2023) Tc = Tm to the power p, the p factor per film, no correction at 1 second or less, and the HP5 Plus example 10 s to 20 s.
- Kodak E-31: Reciprocity and special filter data for Kodak films (2002) The reciprocity law holds from about 1/5 to 1/1,000 s; the Tri-X class table with development changes; the advice to open the lens rather than add time.
- Kodak Professional T-MAX 100 data sheet (F-4016, 2018) T-MAX 100 long-exposure corrections: 1 s +1/3 stop, 10 s to 15 s, 100 s to 200 s, no development change.
- Kodak Professional Portra 400 data sheet (E-4050, 2016) No correction from 1/10,000 to 1 second; for longer exposures, make tests.
- Fujifilm Professional Data Guide (2005) Time and filter corrections for Velvia, Velvia 100F, Provia 100F and Provia 400F.
Made by EASYTECH, who also make LightMeter Pro.